By Michael Phillips 2014-10-17

Tribune Newspapers Critic

2 stars

The new animated feature "The Lorax," known in its entirety as "Dr. Seuss' The Lorax" to keep it straight from "John Grisham's The Lorax," does a few smaller things right but the bigger things not quite. I've come to fear these movies. I love Seuss so much, even his second-shelf works. Who doesn't feel protective of authors and illustrators they love? And not just because we were young when we made their acquaintance.

As with "Horton Hears a Who!" four years ago, the production design and computer-generated animation in this new "Lorax" respect the basic lines of Theodor Seuss Geisel's illustrations, his voluptuously curvy universe of serious whimsy. Both the "Horton" and "Lorax" films work better, certainly, than the live-action Seuss pictures "How the Grinch Stole Christmas" and the seriously not-good "Cat in the Hat."

"The Lorax" is a little more like it. A little. But you couldn't accuse the film of practicing what it preaches: careful stewardship of a precious resource.

The message tends to get lost in all the clanging slapstick and "Wall-E" imagery. "Wall-E" had the courage of its convictions as well as beauty and artistry; "The Lorax" is just another OK feature-length animated edition (in 3-D, if you choose to pay for it) of a Dr. Seuss book.

The filmmakers, headed by director Chris Renaud and screenwriters Ken Daurio and Cinco Paul, all of "Despicable Me," regard the 1971 Seuss book's pro-environmentalist entreaties seriously in theory, not so much in practice. Cooked-up elements include a corporate megalomaniac villain and a pair of nominally sympathetic young humans. The Lorax in "The Lorax," the guardian of the trees voiced, dully, by Danny DeVito, is even more secondary than he was in the book.

In this version of Thneedville, no living thing grows: Trees and shrubs are inflatable plastic, the town is maintained with "Truman Show"-like fakery and the apparent mayor of the town, Mr. O'Hare (Rob Riggle), has made his millions selling bottled air. Young Ted (voiced by Zac Efron) is eager to impress the teenage Audrey (Taylor Swift), so he seeks out the faraway Once-ler (Ed Helms) who holds the secret to what Audrey wants most: a living tree, a reminder of better, greener days.

Most of the picture, as did the book, unfolds as a flashback to the Once-ler's rabid capitalistic youth, when he harvested the precious Truffula tree for its velvety tufts and commercial prospects. Taking its cue from a single line in the original about the Once-ler's family, "The Lorax" brings in a venal hick crowd straight out of"Million Dollar Baby" to underscore the moral about greed being bad. The young Once-ler doesn't question his own business goals, and can't see the forest of his misjudgments for all the trees he's leveling.

A good deal of this comes from the original slim volume by Seuss. By the time the good doctor published his warning about despoiling our planet willy-nilly (cue the Fox News objections!), his adopted home base, La Jolla, Calif., had become a swank coastal holdout to the schmutzy LA smog a two-hour drive north. Every book comes from somewhere; Seuss', I'm guessing, came from his concern over the threatened devaluation of paradise, Southern California style.

The book, unusually blunt and even humorless for Seuss, has become a conflicted diversionary tactic on screen. Its makers were plainly nervous about selling the message. And so they gussy it up with lots of vehicular chase sequences and musical numbers of uneven quality and after a while you long for another trip to see the Once-ler, just because he's a loner and you could use the break. "The Lorax," comes back around by the end to where it needs to be, i.e., in Seuss' corner. But there's a lyric about life in Thneedville painting the place as "plastic and fake and they liked it that way!" And it's too close to the movie's truth for actual moviegoing comfort.

MPAA rating: PG (for brief mild language).

Running time: 1:34.

Voice Cast: Danny DeVito (The Lorax); Zac Efron (Ted); Taylor Swift (Audrey); Ed Helms (The Once-ler); Betty White (Grammy Norma).

Credits: Directed by Chris Renaud and Kyle Balda; written by Ken Daurio and Cinco Paul, based on the book "Dr. Seuss' The Lorax," by Dr. Seuss; produced by Christopher Meledandri and Janet Healy. A Universal Pictures release.

Back to Movie Details

Movie News

FILE - Frank Mankiewicz is seen in this Aug. 7, 1972 file photo at Sen. George McGovern's, downtown Washington Democratic campaign headquarters. The press secretary who announced the death of Robert F. Kennedy, Frank Mankiewicz (MAN-ka-witz), died Thursday Oct. 23, 2014. He was 90.  (AP Photo/File)
Frank Mankiewicz, aide to Robert Kennedy, diesFrank Mankiewicz, political aide who announced RFK's death and ran McGovern campaign, dies
The Associated Press3 hours ago
Steinbeck heirs fight over control of movie rightsAuthor John Steinbeck's heirs tussle over control of movie rights
The Associated Press10 hours ago
This image released by IFC Films shows Ellar Coltrane at age six in a scene from the film,"Boyhood." Richard Linklater’s 12-year-long family drama “Boyhood” leads the Gotham Independent Film Awards with four nominations including best feature. The Independent Filmmaker Project, which presents the awards, announced nominations Thursday, Oct. 23, 2014, for its 24th annual awards to take place December 1 in New York. The Gothams honor independent film and mark one of the first galas in the film industry’s lengthy awards season. (AP Photo/IFC Films)
'Boyhood' tops Gotham Awards with 4 nominations'Boyhood' tops Gotham Independent Film Awards with 4 nominations, including best feature
The Associated Press17 hours ago
In this image released by Magnolia Pictures, Shailene Woodley, from left, Gabourey Sidibe and Mark Indelicato appear in a scene from "White Bird in a Blizzard." (AP Photo/Magnolia Pictures)
Review: Shailene Woodley gets lost in a blizzardFilm review: Appealing Shailene Woodley gets caught in a strange and campy 'Blizzard'
The Associated Press1 day ago
Renee Zellweger attends ELLE's 21st annual Women In Hollywood Awards at the Four Seasons Hotel on Monday, Oct. 20, 2014, in Los Angeles. (Photo by John Shearer/Invision/AP)
Renee Zellweger: 'People don't know me in my 40s'Renee Zellweger responds to talk of her appearance: 'People don't know me in my 40s'
The Associated Press1 day ago
Movie News